Let me tell a story of how I ended up playing in a sub-optimal fit at the 5 level. I say fit but I mean break. One of the opponents had as many trumps as my partner and I combined.
Here's my hand and the auction:
| ♠ | Q 5 4 3 |
| ♥ | A 9 3 |
| ♦ | J T |
| ♣ | Q T 7 6 |
| North | East | South | West |
| 1♣ |
1♦ |
1♠ |
2♦ |
| 3♦ |
Pass |
3♥ |
Pass |
| 4♣ |
Pass |
5♣ |
5♦ |
| 5♥ |
Pass |
Pass |
Pass |
That's me sitting South. Here are some insights into what I thought was going on:
- 3♦ asks for a diamond stop which I sure don't have.
- Maybe if I bid 3♥ we can play in a Moysian 4♥ or 4♠.
- 5♥ thoroughly confuses me.
Some conflicting insights from my partner:
- 3♦ is a cue raise in spades, I'd double if I wanted a stop.
- 3♥ cue, 4♣ cue, 5♣ must be a singleton
- 5♥ another cue on the way to 5♠
Here comes the layout:
| | ♠ | K J 8 7 |
|---|
| ♥ | K 6 |
|---|
| ♦ | 8 |
|---|
| ♣ | A K J 4 3 2 |
|---|
|
| ♠ | A T 9 6 |
|---|
| ♥ | Q T 8 5 4 |
|---|
| ♦ | 9 6 4 3 |
|---|
| ♣ | - |
|---|
|  | | ♠ | 2 |
|---|
| ♥ | J 7 2 |
|---|
| ♦ | A K Q 7 5 2 |
|---|
| ♣ | 9 8 5 |
|---|
|
| | ♠ | Q 5 4 3 |
|---|
| ♥ | A 9 3 |
|---|
| ♦ | J T |
|---|
| ♣ | Q T 7 6 |
|---|
|
When the phrase "bid to the level of the fit" was coined it wasn't meant to mean "if you have a 5 card fit play at the 5 level". Yet here I am. I think we can forgive the defense for not extracting the maximum value here but -250 did score better than some who were in 5
♠x.