10 June 2011

When is a reverse not a reverse?

I know a lot of people have strong feelings about what "standard bidding" means. Sometimes I think it should have a capital letter. Here's your chance to give your opinion on what turned out to be a much more contentious issue than I anticipated.

I'm reasonably confident the range of your NT won't be a factor here but strong club players might not have the same views Here's the auction:

NorthEastSouthWest
1♣ 1♠ 2♦ Pass
2♥

I'm interested in any and all points of view on this. I think 2♥ is always forcing but does it show the extras of a reverse and is it game forcing? Would it make a difference if South were dealer and North had opened after two passes?

I'm asking is the above auction most similar to this:

NorthEastSouthWest
1♥ Pass 2♣ Pass
2♠

Or this?
NorthEastSouthWest
1♥ Pass 2♣ Pass
2♦